Thursday, 29 May 2014

Shadows of old regimes in Egypt's 2014 presidential elections

Preliminary results of Egypt's presidential polls signal a landslide win for ex-army chief Abd El-Fattah El-Sisi. Initial figures give him over 95% of the votes. 

El-Sisi enjoys a wide popularity among Egyptians since he deposed Islamist president Mohamed Morsi amid nationwide protests against him in July 2013. So these results are a victory for many of his supporters who vehemently oppose the Muslim Brotherhood or even the revolutionary youth - seen as "rash" or "unpatriotic". 

However, for many young people El-Sisi is a new Mubarak, against whom they revolted in 2011. And his presidential victory, especially with such popular support, falls heavy upon them. 

Many young social media users circulated photos of old-regime media content, that either hit the credibility of its figures or reflected a lack of change over the years.



This great shot by photographer Mohamed El-Shahed for AFP is of a wall on a Cairo street bearing two front pages of state-owned daily newspapers Al-Akhbar (L) and Al-Gomhouriya (R). The headlines show old promises of the army and the Brotherhood, claiming they don't aspire for power... when in fact time has shown that they both sought it later.

Al-Akhbar's headline reads, "The Muslim Brotherhood does not seek presidency... or government posisitions", while Al-Gomhourihya says, "The military institution will not nominate or support anyone for presidency." 

The Brotherhood put Mohamed Morsi forward for presidential elections in 2012, and the army did the same with El-Sisi in 2014. 


* * * 
As for the huge margin in the poll results, some social media users pulled out the front pages of state-owned newspapers during Gamal Abd El-Nasser's and Mubarak's reigns. 

Wednesday, 28 May 2014

Egypt Elections Headlines: Before & after voting extension


Egyptian newspapers came out on the eve of 27 May, at the end of the first voting day, with celebratory front pages, praising what they described as a heavy turnout at the polling stations. 

Some highlighted women's participation in the presidential elections, while others claimed a presence for young people. (Whose participation has in fact been dwindling & social media has been rampant with sarcasm on "elderly participation" over the past two days.)

However, the following day's front pages saw an obvious change of tone in most papers when Egypt's Presidential Elections Committee (PEC) announced extending the polling for a third day - due to low turnout! 

(Note: current official approximate figures puts turnout at 37%)

So here are snap-shots of yesterday's and today's main state-owned and privately-owned Egyptian daily newspapers. I also wrote an English translation of the headlines. 

- Click on the photos for a larger view.

* * *

Al-Ahram

(State-owned daily) 


27 May 2014 
28 May 2014


27 May:        
Egyptians are making the future 
A popular carnival on the first voting day 

28 May:
Voting extended for 24 hours 
Heavy turnout at polling stations in a festive atmosphere 

* * * 

Al-Akhbar 

(State-owned daily) 

28 May 2014
27 May 2014

 27 May:       
Egypt fascinates the world 
Youth turnout... and women are at the forefront
Muslim Brotherhood fails to ruin the democratic festival 

28 May:
Voting extended to today...  Sisi and Sabahi object


Tuesday, 27 May 2014

Links & Videos: Online media round-up of Egyptian elections

Two only Egyptian presidential candidates Hamdeen Sabahi (L) and Abd El-Fatah El-Sisi (R)

Here some useful links explaining the Egyptian presidential elections taking place at the moment, in addition to the latest updates.

Second day elections round-up:

 

So Egypt's Presidential Elections Committee (PEC) decided to extend the voting for a third day due to low turn out! No holiday is declared. 

(The Telegraph called it "Egypt elections extended as Sisi's backers embarrassed by low turn-out")


Both Sabahi's and El-Sisi's campaigns have filed complaints against the decision. 

However, PEC has rejected these legal complaints. PEC's secretary Abd El-Aziz Salman told CBC TV channel: "We do not abide by the desires of the candidates. We are following the popular wishes... two representative of a popular delegation came to the committee's headquarters to request more opportunities to vote."

Meanwhile, there are calls on social media asking Sabahi to withdraw from the race, saying the elections are a farce. 

* * *

As participation levels were unexpectedly low, there have been efforts from the Egyptian government & media to urge people to vote. Aswat Masriya has more to say indeed in this feature titled "Vote or else, Egyptian media warns public". 

Egypt's PM Ibrahim Mahlab also announced a fine of EGP 500 for those who do not vote. (Same news about a fine were announced in previous elections). 

Anyway, here are some other news on the second elections day in Egypt...

Journalists on the street

- BBC crew briefly detained when interviewing Rabaa widow (DNE) 

- Journalists detained, barred from polling stations: Syndicate (Ahram Online)

Monitoring the elections: 

- Ahram Online interviews chief observer of the European Union's Election Observation Mission (EOM) in Egypt. 

How did the second day unfold? 

- Ahram Online's live updates

- At least 30 arrests during presidential elections (DNE)

Egypt-specials: 

- Reports on social media saying that shopping complex City Stars in northern Cairo shut down early to "call on people to vote". This video from local news publication El-Badil features an announcement broadcast in City Stars, telling customers it will close at 4 p.m. CLT in order to help staff vote.

Commentary: 

- Robert Fisk writes in The Independent: "Egypt elections: The coronation of the emperor".


Earlier today: 
The government has declared Tuesday an official holiday in the public sector to facilitate the polling process & extended the voting for an extra hour. 

Here are also some links for what has been happening in the early morning: 

- Sabahi campaign urges Egypt youth to back him on final polling day (Ahram Online)

- Dostour (Constitution) Party Facebook pages launches an event called "Tuesday is for Hamdeen" to urge voters to cast their votes for the only candidate against El-Sisi Today. 

Trending hashtags

انسحب_يا_حمدين# (Withdraw, Hamdeen)

كملوا_المسرحية# (Continue the show)

الاربع_بتاع_حمدين# (Wednesday is for Hamdeen) 


Tuesday, 11 February 2014

Victims: Journalists vs the Public

We were always taught in university that journalism is the "fourth estate", a watchdog on those in power, a force that challenges them and keeps them alert for they know someone will hold them accountable. But, more importantly, this "fourth estate" is on a noble mission to give voice to the voiceless, bring attention to the unnoticed, and shed light upon what's been cast in the dark. Our professors told us time and time again that: journalism should reveal wrongdoing, raise awareness and demand justice - it is an active (and much needed) player in democracy.

And so journalism suddenly became the most intriguing thing that I ever came across, especially that this happened after the 2011 revolution when the whole country was bubbling with enthusiasm.

I was quite lucky to have worked with colleagues in on-campus newspapers who were (and some still are) vehement believers in such values of journalism. They were extremely enthusiastic about the potential impact news can make. We reported night and day on stories, interviewed tens of people, discussed scenarios and plans for hours - thinking this was our next journalistic breakthrough, that we'd be our university's Woodward and Bernstein.

It was all about "let's do some real journalism" - and to me, this "real" journalism was always about the story. We wanted to find the important stories, the good stories, work properly on them and get them published.

However, I started to feel recently that it isn't actually always about the story. A lot of the time it's more about the journalist. And this issue can have a lot of elements to look at and factors to consider. But what really drew my attention recently is how reporters are treated with superiority when it comes to situations where they are jailed, injured or killed.

The argument is that journalists are out risking their security to inform everyone else of the truth. And if you arrest or kill a journalist - you're silencing a channel of vital communication. And so the significance of the crackdown is doubled - you do not only trespass over a human being's freedom, but you deny the public the important service this journalist is giving them.

Sunday, 10 November 2013

Inside Egypt's Muslim Sisterhood

Supporters of Morsi shout slogans as they continue a sit-in protest outside the Rabaa al-Adawiya mosque in Cairo (Photo: Reuters)

[This story was originally published on Ahram Online on 7 October 2013] 

As army tanks came to a halt in front of a group of protesters lying in the road, the air thick with teargas, Wafaa Hefny didn’t hesitate.
“I walked up to the soldiers standing on each tank and said ‘your mothers will curse you. Do not fire at your brothers - go back,’” she recalls. “All the tanks moved back.”
Hefny, 46, is a university instructor and an active Muslim Brotherhood member. Speaking at home, she wears a crimson traditional dress, her hair streaked with a few grey lines. 
When security forces began to disperse a sit-in by supporters of Brotherhood president Mohamed Morsi at Rabaa Al-Adawiya on 14 August, Hefny and her husband immediately went there.
Hefny had spent several weeks camping at the Rabaa protest with her family. When she arrived at the site - in Cairo's Nasr City - she found no way in. So she joined people going to nearby Al-Tayaran Street where they forced tanks to retreat. 
After her encounter with the tanks, she spent the night transporting dead bodies out of the ruins of Rabaa. 
Women on the streets
Hefny was not the only female member of the Brotherhood who took to Cairo’s streets when the protest camps were dispersed.

Though the Brotherhood, an 85-year-old Islamist group founded by Hassan El-Banna, is seen as a male-dominant group, it has a lot of “sisters” who participate in different roles. They may not, however, reach leading positions or rise to the fore after a lot of the men were arrested recently.
“Women are more active on the street than men,” Sameh Eid, a former member of the Brotherhood, tells Ahram Online. 
“They engage actively in public relations and elections campaigns; they are passionate and enthusiastic members,” he says.

Policewomen patrol women's carriages on Cairo's packed metro

Colonel Roqayah El-Seify speaking to women passengers in the metro (Photo: Reem Gehad)

[This story was originally published on Ahram Online on 2 October 2013] 

As crowds increase on Cairo’s underground with the return to school and closure of a central station connecting two main metro lines, a female police force has appeared on busy trains. 
Colonel Roqayah El-Seify, 57, saluted high-ranking officials as she walked into the police office at Shohada metro station in downtown Cairo, one of the city’s busiest stations.
She wore a white police suit, pink-coloured make-up and a black headscarf under her police cap. 
“We work with policemen in order to secure and protect the metro - trains and stations,” she told Ahram Online. 
The female force on the metro includes officers and lower-ranking police personnel. El-Seify says at least ten women are part of this force. They come from a larger women's division within the Interior Ministry, recruited mostly from administrative positions. 
Their task in the metro is primarily focused on the two carriages allocated for women on each train. 
“We secure these carriages through moving patrols inside them, raising awareness of pickpockets, beggars and harassers,” she said. 
Passengers in the female-only carriages often complain about men who ride in them, especially during late hours, as sexual harassment has become a daily issue for most women in Cairo. 
More than 99 percent of hundreds of women surveyed in seven of the country's 27 governorates reported experiencing some form of sexual harassment, ranging from minor harassment to rape, according to a report issued by the UN, Egypt's Demographic Centre and the National Planning Institute in April.

Egyptian Social Democratic Party: From opposition to cabinet leaders

PM Hazem El-Beblawi (L) and deputy PM Ziad Bahaa El-Din (R) (Photo: Ahram)

[This story was originally published on Ahram Online on 23 July 2013]

Founded after the January 25 Revolution, the Egyptian Social Democratic Party (ESDP) sits at the top of the government in the post-Morsi transitional period.
Prime Minister Hazem El-Beblawi and Deputy Prime Minister Ziad Bahaaeddin are founding members of the centre-left liberal party. As heads of the government, they are now looked upon to solve pressing issues, including economic problems, severe political divisions and the security vacuum.
El-Beblawi, a liberal economist, leads a largely secular government following president Mohamed Morsi's ouster by the army on 3 July amid mass protests against his rule.
The new government marks a change from former prime minister Hisham Qandil's cabinet which was mostly comprised of Muslim Brothers or their Islamist sympathisers.
Ahram Online profiles the ESDP and examines its views and stances on current political affairs.
ESDP’s relationship with the new cabinet
The party released a statement saying that it would play no role in the formation of the cabinet and would not interfere in its work once it is sworn in.
The PM and deputy PM were chosen by [interim President Adly Mansour] because they are competent, Ahmed Fawzi, ESDP general-secretary said. “We are proud, as a party, to have qualified people to fill such positions.”
However, Fawzi stressed the cabinet is not the “party’s cabinet.”
Mohamed Abul-Ghar, head of the ESDP and one of its founders, described El-Beblawi and Bahaaeddin as “independent technocrats” in an interview with Ahram Online on Sunday.
Indeed, the cabinet does not contain any other ESDP members. However, the party has expressed satisfaction with the new government.
“There are many ministers whose ideas are similar to ours, including Manpower Minister Kamal Abu-Eita [labour activist and head of the Egyptian Federation of Independent Trade Unions] and Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Higher Education Hossam Eissa [former leading member of the Constitution Party],” Fawzi said.
Abul-Ghar described the cabinet as “reasonable,” adding that “people are happy with some appointments as they belong to the revolution.”
“In fact, the party has made a sacrifice by agreeing to the appointments,” Fawzi added. “If their performance is unsatisfactory for the people at this critical time, it will directly affect us.”
Economic Views 
For many, and the ESDP is no different, the interim cabinet’s first priority should be overcoming the economic crisis.
However, Fawzi said El-Beblawi would not implement an ESDP economic programme during his premiership.
“The current cabinet should help stop the crisis from worsening,” he said. “We should not expect it to revive the economy with a comprehensive programme - it is a temporary government.”
The ESDP advocates social and economic justice, viewing the private sector and free market policies as the most productive and efficient way to organise the economy, albeit with a measure of state regulation.
The party also supports the inflow of foreign direct investment within a regulatory framework that prevents monopolistic practices.
Indeed, PM El-Beblawi, who previously served as finance minister and deputy prime minister for economic affairs in 2011, said in an interview with state TV on Sunday that he supports a “free market system, but with government regulation.”
He spoke of foreign investment, from the US and the Arab World, saying that Egypt’s choice should be “openness and cooperation with the world.”
In the past two weeks, Egypt has received $12 billion in aid from the oil-rich Gulf states of Kuwait, Saudi Arabia and the UAE.
However, according to Samer Atallah, an assistant professor of economics at the American University in Cairo, the interim cabinet’s economic challenge lies elsewhere.
“The government has members from the left and the right. I am sceptical that this will create a common agenda,” he told Al-Ahram Weekly on 17 July.
“For example, you have someone like Abu-Eita who strongly opposes the IMF loan and you have El-Beblawi and [Finance Minister] Ahmed Galal who are advocates of the loan,” Atallah added.
Meanwhile, El-Beblawi stressed in his televised interview that he is looking to implementing a law setting minimum and maximum wages, a long-awaited demand since the January 2011 uprising.
ESDP’s relationship with the Muslim Brotherhood
The ESDP is a liberal party that advocates a strictly secular state. In this regard, it opposes Mohamed Morsi's Muslim Brotherhood and its political arm, the Freedom and Justice Party (FJP).
The ESDP is a member of the National Salvation Front (NSF), Egypt's main coalition of liberal and leftist parties, which is a major opponent of the Brotherhood and participated in the anti-Morsi protests on 30 June.
In the current situation, where Morsi supporters are calling for his reinstatement, actions are being made for reconciliation.
Egypt’s presidential aide for political affairs Mustafa Hegazy announced last Wednesday that communications regarding national reconciliation would start this week.
Abul-Ghar said his party had tried to reach out to the Brotherhood as it “does not want revenge.”
“[However], the Brotherhood doesn't reach out to us, they don't answer anything. We would like them to join the political arena.”
El-Beblawi’s cabinet does not include any Islamist figures. But according to Abul-Ghar the Brotherhood and the Salafist Nour Party were invited to join but refused.
On Sunday, the Brotherhood said it rejected the current situation and would not back down on its demand for Morsi’s reinstatement. It also called for dialogue, after Morsi's return to the presidency, with "all political forces."
For Abul-Ghar, a potential reconciliation would include releasing prisoners “unless somebody did something that deserves legal consideration.”
Fawzy said reconciliation is welcome with Egypt’s Islamist forces, but only with figures who had not “commited crimes.”
Several leading Brotherhood members were detained after Morsi’s ouster on charges including incitement of violence. Morsi himself has been held incommunicado at an unknown location since 3 July.
Relationship with the military
The ESDP was among the groups that opposed the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces (SCAF) when it held power from president Hosni Mubarak’s ouster in February 2011 until Morsi’s election in June 2012.
It was critical of SCAF’s “mismanagement” of the post-revolution scene. After army chief and defence minister Abdel-Fattah El-Sisi announced Morsi's removal, the Brotherhood called it a “military coup.”
Debates were triggered in the media over the extent of the army’s role in politics. El-Sisi was then appointed first deputy prime minister and has maintained his position as defence minister in the interim cabinet.
“The military should stay the same. The defence minister has always been the head of army,” Abul-Ghar said. He added that the army “is not in charge” and “the cabinet was formed independently.”
El-Beblawi said in a televised interview that the first time he spoke to El-Sisi was when they took the oath together.
ESDP in parliament
In the 2011/2012 parliamentary elections, the ESDP participated as part of the Egyptian Bloc, a coalition of leftist and liberal forces. Originally comprised of 21 groups, after several defections the Bloc finally included the ESDP, the Free Egyptians Party, and the Tagammu Party.
The ESDP won 16 seats (out of 498) in the People's Assembly, parliament’s lower house, ranking highest in the bloc. In the Shura Council elections, the upper house of parliament, it won eight seats.
However, shortly before Morsi’s ouster, all party members submitted their resignations from the Islamist-dominated 270-seat Shura Council in solidarity with the 30 June protests. About 34 Shura Council members, from secular forces, also submitted their resignations.
On 14 July, Abul-Ghar told Sada El-Balad TV channel that the parties in the NSF would run under one unified list in upcoming parliamentary elections.
However, the NSF is currently facing internal troubles after its head Mohamed ElBaradei and general-secretary Mounir Fakhry Abdel-Nour left their positions to become vice-president and industry minister respectively.